Friday, November 11, 2016

Things fall apart...

The title of this post is taken from a Yeats poem called The Second Coming. Here's the first part of that poem, it has always sort of haunted me:

Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.

The last lines of that poem are also shivery and scary:

And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?

I've been grieving and thinking about the unprecedented fit of ugly self-destructiveness that is (to me anyway) manifested by the 2016 presidential election outcome.

The U.S. has put into power a white man who has never held elected office nor has ever held any appointed government position or served in any military position or rank.

He's outed himself as a racist misogynist who is likely also a pedophile or child raper. Anyone who has even a moderate amount of judgement can detect that he is afflicted with serious emotional and cognitive problems but...that doesn't seem to matter to those who voted for him.

This is who those voters selected to represent them as their leader...this is who they have turned over control of all the nuclear weapons to. This is what has happened...and I am frightened.

In case you didn't know...that's never happened in the history of this place called the U.S.A. I will has never happened before that a man elected president has never had any position in the military or government. Never.

You can, if you want, read more about that here.

If I consider what's happened during my lifetime, it sort of appears to me that the nation seems to let the destroyers and harmers nibble away at the economy and the planet and the people until the harm gets so great and so enough white people...that there's a big flurry and push for helping the economy and (white) people.

This nation mostly doesn't much care about harming people who aren't white men. If you disagree, I invite you to examine the history of the U.S. and please let me know where you find something different. (Realize that I'm speaking in generalities, broad swaths or trends not unconnected instances. As far as I can see...every instance of help to the less powerful was in some way or another connected with helping white men either in substance or prompted by shaming and worries about how white people here might appear to the rest of the world.)  You might learn something by looking at history from the viewpoint of such harming/helping and if you find something that means I need to revise my thinking...then I learn too. Ok?

Before I was born that's what seemed to lead to the election of FDR and the subsequent reforms and guarantees for average people (white) that came into place under him. I'm looking at the civil rights movement and subsequent legislation that came from it as being essentially a continuation and completing of that supporting of the less powerful citizens in the U.S.

Let's say FDR started changing things in 1935 and this period of assisting the less powerful ended in 1965 with the voting rights act. I'm skipping over lots of stuff, I know...but stay with me here. Since 1965 the power group (white wealthy men and their cohorts and hangers on) have been working to dismantle those helpings and to increase their harming/destroying of the planet and the people and the economy. They were doing it all along but I'm using 1965 as a marker date for the onslaught of harming and the essential end of the repairing.

What led to FDR and the national sentiment to help the less powerful and take away power from the wealthy white men was an economic devastation so profound that at one time the unemployment rate was about 25%. Now understand that the 25% who were unemployed were non-wealthy white men. Note that now whenever the unemployment rate for that group gets to 6 or 7% or more everyone gets excited (I'm glossing over, my apologies, how marginalized group folks always always have higher unemployment rates than white men).

So FDR comes in with a large majority pushing for fixing and helping that begins in 1935 and all that pretty much ends in 1965. We've essentially been in a period of harming ever since then...that's for over 50 years. Power has been generally been being taken from those with less power and being gathered by those with power (I'm painting in large strokes here).

And here we are...we've elected to the presidency the most egregiously unfit person I've ever seen...and we've had some really bad and awful men there before. He is openly aligned almost totally with the harmers and abusers and with wealthy white men.

And right now, I think one of the biggest factors that led to his election was that Barack Obama was black and was the president and that absolutely terrified and unhinged white men...and white women. Even though, in large and small ways, Barack Obama's policies were on the side of the harmers.

It was his blackness that terrified them and in their derangement they've put a white man in power who is the epitome of someone who has no regard for any marginalized group. He cares not one whit for people of color, for women, for poor people, for disabled people, for LBGTQIA grouping of humans with little or no social power has any significance to him at all. They are prey.

I suspect we might be entering the end phase, the crescendo of the 51 years of harming that's been working to tear up the fixing that began with FDR.

And...if all this broad picture looking is's likely to result in some disaster (like 25% unemployment rates for white men) to provide enough ooch for those who oppose harm to come together enough to start fixing again.

I don't know what form the coming disaster might take...but I strongly suspect one is coming. And many are going to be harmed...and it will mostly be those with little or no power but it will eventually harm white men too.

I fear that we all (except wealthy white men) are going to be damaged...maybe severely...maybe even unprecedentedly disastrously before this is all over. Maybe fatally...I don't know...I do know it's going to be awful. And it's going to be totally unnecessary. We (white people) could have done better than this long ago...but we didn't and it seems we won't until it gets so horrid that we have to do better. That happens...but we don't seem to learn...we get forced to do better but our thinking doesn't seem to change much.

As I wrote that last sentence it struck me that there is one group that (I'm speaking on average) that never gets hurt is...guess who...wealthy folks. Come what may, the wealthy (mostly white men) might get dinged, but they don't get hurt. They don't end up starving or out of work or lynched or enslaved or beaten up or imprisoned.

That's true...why don't we understand that then they should never ever have power because they don't have to deal with the consequences of awful?

Hmmm...I'd never thought of that in quite the way I'm thinking of it now. Consider...if you wanted a human society that did the most positive stuff for the greatest would always put in power those who were most interested in helping the least powerful and who would be most impacted by harm to the least powerful. Hmmm. Think about that for a minute.

That would be the way to go if you wanted to do the greatest good for the largest number of folks because...helping the least would automatically result in either neutral or good for those more powerful than the least powerful. If you lift the raises everyone...right?

Well...if that's true, and I suspect it is, then we've done the exact opposite. We've put into power one of the most powerful who is an abuser and a harmer and is intent on helping those with all the power. He wants to raise up those already high and screw those who are lower or less powerful.

I don't think this is going to end well and I'm unwilling to rule out a devastation that makes WWII look like a birthday party. When harmers are supported by a large swath of the population (by that I mean those who put this man in power) then the likelihood of awfulness for every human without much power...for all living beings without much power, is almost a certainty. I suspect he may end up harming everyone...even those who think they are insulated from harm.

I hope that isn't true...but I fear that it is.

I'll continue to think about this and also to think about ways to maybe counter it however I can. You think about it too and let me know what occurs to you. Hey...people who are much better writers and thinkers than I am are writing about all this too. One of those writer's articles is here.

I'm pretty sure no wealthy white men read this you who do read it are among those who are at risk of being hurt by what's probably coming and your thoughts about stopping it or decreasing it or preventing it are welcome. I'm really saddened about this and I''m profoundly ashamed of us white people. This did not have to be.

I've been writing about and thinking much about race and racism here in the U.S. for quite some you know permeates this society...and it is destroying all of us.


Patty Ann said...

For the past 8-10 years many of the new articles and opinion pieces that I've read have pulled my thoughts to The French Revolution. I fear that not until the majority of our society have been dragged into poverty, pulled down by despair and feeling of hopelessness there will be no change. I find it soul destroying that there are so many people who lack a sense of altruism, compassion & empathy nor willingness to elect Lawmakers who will consider the most vulnerable members of our society before initiating policies. The older that I get and the more that I know the less hope I harbor for the Human Species.

veganelder said...

Thank you for commenting Patty Ann. How are you? It's good to see that you visit here.

I wrestle with despair too...and yet...if I think of people I know...including family members who did vote for's difficult for me to perceive them as "bad" people. I know there are despicable folks around...but that wasn't who made up the majority of those who voted for him. It was people who, I think, are basically "decent" but somehow are deeply flawed in their thinking and/or judgement.

The older I get the more I think it's incumbent on me to struggle to find ways to reach them. I do know this all is pretty much totally a white people problem and we white people must remedy this in some form or fashion.

Some time ago the solution to the vegan issue hit me that if every vegan just was able to get one other person to go vegan...then it wouldn't be long until it was a majority vegan country. Same with these basically "decent" people...I think it's on our backs (white folks who do care) to do the had and unfun work of bringing them by one if that's what it takes.

I'm lucky enough to have been a spark for 4 people who went vegan that refer to me as their inspiration to do so. And I didn't proselytize...I just talked a little sometimes. So I know things like that can happen...the race delusion may be more can be done.

I suspect part of what has prolonged and deepened the awful thinkings among "decent" folks is the failure of us who perhaps think a bit more clearly to believe that was enough...that if we could behave well then we did our job. I think maybe that's wrong...maybe we need to work harder at helping others to think/comprehend better.

But...who am I, ya know.

Thank you again for commenting.

Have Gone Vegan said...

It's been almost two weeks since the election, and while I wasn't surprised (reading and participating in some heated and polarized online discussions I could see where this was heading), it was still a shock. How have I felt since the Donald was elected? Let me count the D's: dejected, dismayed, disgusted, disbelieving, demoralized, depressed, defeated... And I live in Canada! So I can well imagine how at least half of the Americans who voted are feeling.

Some readers might ask, why would Canadians even care? Well, because we're neighbours, because US policies will have an impact not only on us, but worldwide, because this election received massive daily coverage so Canadians couldn't get away from it even if we tried, and because as a generally more left-leaning country, we empathized with those who care about progressive values. Plus, like many other countries, we couldn't believe what was happening.

But sadly, the spillover effect has already been noticed. Within the last two weeks there has been a dramatically marked increase in hate crimes here. It's like even Canadians have somehow been given permission to express their racism more openly. So much for being a supposedly more liberal country. Scary stuff.

I do think dark days are ahead (well, they're already here), and I worry that so many groups, including other sentient beings, are going to feel the brunt of this. :(

veganelder said...

Thank you for commenting HGV. I would point out to you that, due to our system, Mr. Trump is not yet the president...that selection will occur on December 19th when the Electoral College votes. Those electors can, according to the constitution, vote for anyone they choose. Part of their purpose is prevent unfit persons from becoming president even if such persons win the popular elections in various states.

If no one gets a majority in the Electoral College vote, the U.S. House of Representatives then select who will serve as the president.

The surge in hate crimes here and in your country will hopefully give pause to those electors...even in those where some small penalty is levied against elector who doesn't follow the popular vote in their state. It is unprecedented in the history of the U.S. for someone who lost the popular vote by the margin that Mr. Trump has (over 2 million more voted for Clinton) to be confirmed as the president.

Maybe the disaster can be averted. We will see. I hope everyone contacts their electors and makes their concerns known.

My biggest worry is letting this unstable and unfit man have control over nuclear weapons. I am profoundly frightened that he's just the sort of disturbed individual who could cause the deaths of millions of Earthlings. Of course his bigotry and commitment to oppression concerns me...but his having the power to kill all of us concerns me more. If we're dead...we can't oppose or resist anything.

Canada and everyone in every nation should be concerned and, frankly, terrified. We are all at serious and profound risk.

Have Gone Vegan said...

Hi veganelder, I share your concern. I don't think the Electoral College has ever voted in enough numbers to overturn the election result though? I'm aware a recount has been called in certain states, but that the outcome likely won't change. I think Jan 20 should be a day of mourning rather than celebration...

And I know some would like to see Trump impeached or brought down in some way, but then that means Pence would be in charge (although some say he actually WILL be doing the work and Trump made more the marketer), and he's a scary dude as well. A history of anti-women sentiment and action, and a believer of gay conversion therapy for heaven's sake! Scary times ahead.

As for nuclear codes, I had assumed that there was a system of checks in place before any button got pushed, and that it couldn't happen just because a toddler like Trump threw a tantrum. At least I hope that's the case!

Still can't believe we'll more likely than not have 4 years of everyone having to watch this man in power...

veganelder said...

Thank you for commenting HGV. You wrote " I don't think the Electoral College has ever voted in enough numbers to overturn the election result though?"

The phrase "overturn the election result" is where I start asking questions like which election result? Does "election result" refer to the result where the most electors were accumulated or to the "election result" where the most citizen votes were accumulate?

I'm convinced that "Americans" are enacting in one of the more amazing examples of social conditioning designed to create invisibility (not comprehending something that's right in front of you). I found one website that points out that you could win over 78% of the popular vote and still lose the election because of the electoral college.

This is not how most citizens envision a presidential race. Most Americans think in terms of voting for their candidate and the candidate with the most votes wins...the presidential election is more like a strange lottery where (historically...if Trump gets installed as president) close to 10% of the time the popular vote loser becomes president. A one in 10 payoff is pretty attractive...think if you won the lotto once for every 10 tickets you bought...or think in reverse...if every 10th time you drove to work you had a serious accident.

That's an "election" where voters choose their representative?

We (American voters) think we vote "for the president"...nope...we're actually voting for the electors...and that's who pick who'll be president. Very few understand this or think this way. We're very brainwashed.

You can read about this travesty here: